c) Compare T.H. Marshall's theory of citizenship with postcolonial critiques. (10 marks)
Ujjwal Priyank, AIR 10, 2025
T.H. Marshall defined citizenship as the entitlement of the members of a political community.
However, post colonial critiques revolved around the rise of new nation-states who are freed from chains of colonial exploitation.
1. T.H. Marshall's citizenship talks about various dimension of rights exerted by members of nation-state. - However, post colonial critique argues that the exploiters have changed from being foreigners to those who are of same nation. 2. Citizenship grants political access to the members of the community through voting rights. - However, critique like Gramsci talk about existence of hegemony of those in power. 3. Citizenship as given by T.H. Marshall explain the existence of various individuals due to the concepts of equality in legal terms. - However, post colonial critique views it as a mere equality in written documents with no major changes in social reality.
Despite these criticism, citizenship today is a global concept that ensures the grant of rights to the legal citizens.