Q.6) a) Discuss the Heartland Theory and critically evaluate its relevance in the 21st-century geopolitical context. (20 marks)
Rohin Kumar, AIR 39, 2025
Heartland theory was propounded by Halford mackinder in his theory & Pivot 1904, later improved, as the Sea based power concept of geopolitical analysis of the world.
Concept of heartland 1. Divided world into Heartland, inner crescent, outer crescent with decreasing geopolitical relevance 2. He recognised the world Island as the region of Eurasia & Africa, that is of high geopolitical complementarity to heartland 3. Crux of theory: - Who Controls Eastern Europe, controls heartland - Who controls heartland, controls the world Island - Who controls the world Island, controls the world
[a world map showing the Heartland in northern Eurasia surrounded by the Inner Crescent and Outer Crescent, with the World Island around them]
fig: Heartland theory
Relevance in 21st century
Applicable today: - (a) NATO expansion in Eastern Europe & Russia Ukraine war since 2022 hints the importance of Eastern Europe as the gateway to heartland - (b) The rising prominence of "world Island" -> with land routes, water routes - China's BRI Projects along silk route - Eurasia Economic union - INSTC, IMEC as transport routes to enhance the relevance of integration - (c) The spill over of geopolitical phenomena to the inner crescent -> Middle East (Gaza crisis), & outer crescent -> factionalism in Africa
Not applicable in 21st century: 1. MacKinder's focus on sea based power only does not hold much water with advent of air power, drones, continental missiles 2. The heartland is largely a zone of adversity (Spykman), seen after fall of USSR 3. Rise of multilateralism & economic interdependence have decentralised the global power to varied actors like Rise of BRICS & dedollarisation
Heartland theory can help in understanding the basics of geopolitical organisation globally but would not sufficiently answer the dynamism in geopolitics.