Topper Copies

Only in the depths of winter can we truly appreciate the warmth of spring.

Ishitwa Anand, AIR 50, 2025

"Just get on with it, you Jew!" shrieked a Nazi SS officer. His fierce command was obeyed by all, and amongst it was Victor Frankl. Treading wearily and dejected he reached at his bunker and pondered: "Oh how dearly I miss those pancakes! A bottle of juice would have made a whole lot of difference," he thought. Alas! It could not be, for he was stationed at one of the concentration camps of Nazis. He was stuck in the depths of winter and now he truly appreciated the warmth of spring.

He later writes in his work: Man's Search for Meaning: "In the abyss of despair; In the abyss of gloom, I truly realised what is to be free. I then truly realised the warmth of your spouse, the love of your parents and the giggles of your children are all what true warmth is about"

The anecdote highlights the essence that it is only in the winters that one realises the value of spring. It is in those trials, tribulations and difficulties that one fully appreciates the worth of comfort etc.

The essay shall seek to unravel the various intricacies of the depths of winter: What are those lows? What factors lead to such piercing winters and the appreciation that it causes for the warmth of summers? Furthermore, we shall also look into why such depths are reached? Can't it be stopped and why ONLY in winters we appreciate the spring? Let's take a deeper dive!

One may ponder about the thought of winters. What is it? Primarily the depths of winter can be understood by a situation where the surrounding is harsh and tough. For instance, lets take the era of 1980s and early 1990s. India had been subjugated to tough times. There was changing political landscape, The unfortunate assassination of our erstwhile Prime Minister Indira Gandhi and nation wide riots. Added to it was the financial crisis of early 1990s. These events had led to a hostile situation for India internally and also externally.

Also, winter is a multifaceted concept. The derivations stretch far beyond the traditional perception. During the depths of winter, there is darkness. This darkness clouds innovation. Take the case of medieval Europe. It was marred by darkness, losing its previous warmth of spring ushered by the rational thinkers of greek world like Socrates, Aristotle and Plato.

In addition to it, The depths of winters are also characterised by a lack of resources. One leads to resource provisioning and waiting for the snow and ice to thaw. This perpetuates status-quo tendencies.

The depths are further characterised by doubts. An individual not being able to stand as per the expectations get drenched into the snow of doubt.

After looking into the manifestations of such depressions we must also understand the factors that lead to it.

The coming of winters is a cyclic phenomenon. The sun revolves and seasons change. Winter leads to spring and so on. Famous explorer Ibn Batuta in his work; Rihla, has also explained the cyclical nature of civilizations. Societies form and decline as well explained by the adage 'Forests Precede civilizations and Deserts Follow Them'.

Also such depressions can be structural. The continent of Africa is a glowing example of it. With such springness all around it in terms of resources, climate and demography it has still been pushed to the abyss of despair, all due to structural issues of corruption, crime etc. Thus winters come and go but structures perpetuate it.

After analysing the depths of winter and factors leading to it, we shall step to the appreciation of spring.

What is appreciation? Is it external appraisal or beyond that. Well appreciation is the true form of regard. When one is empathetic, supererogatory and has a keen eye, appreciation not just stems but it flows.

Such appreciation for the warmth of spring arises from the fact that as one is lost and feels hopeless in winters, one craves for the warmth for vitality. Let's analyse through multiple domains.

In the ancient India, it was during the battle of Kalinga, that emperor Ashoka fell to the depths of agony. This abhorrence for 'bherigoosha' led to kindling of an appreciation for the warmth of 'dhammaghosha' (righteous path).

Forwarding to the medieval era, as the Sultanate rule dawned upon India and traditional crafts suffered, the 'Golden Age' of Guptas was truly remembered.

Even in the technological domain, the same holds true. The United States of America, during the second world war decided to drop atomic bombs over Japan. Such ghastly act led to the realisation of value of peace in the International arena.

In addition to these, the warmth of spring too has revitalising benefits. Just as the spring leads to greenery in the fields, it also leads to prosperity and development of individuals, societies & nations. The true appreciation for the warmth of spring comes to those with a keen eye, with an ability to hold and pause, take moment to retrospect and then move ahead, rather than ignoring and rushing and as famously exemplified by George Santayana in his quote "Those who forget the mistakes in the past are condemned to repeat it"

Travelling through the ideas, a fleeting thought may emerge as to why appreciation of good things take such long time? why wait till the bottom is hit? If only humans are more aware, keen and have an appetite to change ways, such rock bottom can be stopped. The answer to above mentioned questions lies in the nature of humanity. Very cheekily, Albert Einstein had claimed humans to be just a developed form of monkeys. Humans have a tendency to take things for granted. If we see the present case of environmental degradation, this idea holds true.

The Earth as a system is suffering with global warming, melting glaciers and what not. Yet, the global climate governance believes in some miracle to cure our mother Earth. From 'Phasing out' to 'Phasing down' of Coal to a meagre ($300 billion in Climate finance, The Earth is heading towards the depths of winter

Moreover, the habit of status-quo without reforms further pushes humanity to brim. For instance, continued global wars has pushed human consciousness to perils and yet the true appreciation for warmth of peace is not reached.

Finally, the depths of winter lead to complete resetting and thus no opportunity cost exist. The Marshall Plan post World war II was one such warmth provided to winter stricken Europe.

Thus, after detailing the [?] and exercises, the question arises: What must be the correct course? How to ensure true appreciation for the warmth of spring.

The solution lies in the idea that one who does not wait for the depths of winter to linger and appreciates the warmth while it is present leads to sustainability. Taking inspiration from the story of Ant and the Grasshopper we must ensure that we make hay while the sun shines.

To accentuate this, at the Individual level, mindfulness and well being is the way ahead. We must train our soul to be brave and face the challenges of winters. As stoic philosopher Marcus Aurelius says: 'The mind gets dyed in the color of its soul'.

In addition, at the societal level, value inculcation through dialogues, debates and discussion leads to true appreciation of the warmth. An example can be taken from the Scandinavian model of education and social welfare. Despite of it being literally in the depths of winter, it has managed to spread the warmth of spring forever throughout the year through value education, pensions, free health care etc.

At the national level, the true appreciation lies in the collective ethos of the nation. India has not only claimed to be a salad bowl of societies but also preaches through the idea of 'Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam'. Even after loss of partition it has been able to maintain a secular characteristic.

In conclusion, it is true that it is in dire situations that we trully appreciate the idea of peace, tranquility and comfort. All this forms due to prevailing global ideology and internal currents. This often leads to realising the true worth of something after we lose a hold over it.

However, the civilization must ensure that appreciation is not situation dependent and must prevail at all times. The cyclic nature of seasons can change but prosperity can perpetuate even in the darkest of hours and in the toughest of terrains.

As I remain on the winterstrip All but how I reached this dip? If once had heart smiled at spring Today, I would've been on a jolly string.