c) Discuss the relationship between population-resource regions and Malthusian theory. (15 marks)
Rohin Kumar, AIR 39, 2025
Malthus in 1798 propounded this concept of population-resource dynamism as population growth at geometric rate with resource growth at the arithmetic rate.
Concept - Positive checks: Epidemics, wars, conflicts - Preventive checks: moral restraint, delay marriage
Population resource regions & Malthus Malthus discuss the significance of Carrying capacity of a region determined by the geodemographic load of the region.
[a four-quadrant graph of resource availability (vertical axis) against population density (horizontal axis): high resource/low population as Siberia, high resource/high population as the Indo-Gangetic plain, low population/low resource as the Sahara desert, and high population/poor resource marked as the Malthusian crisis zone]
fig: Malthusian logic
1. Low population low resource regions are more or less self sustaining with Indigenous communities relying on local resource 2. High Population & High density regions again experience optimal availability 3. High resource poor Population -> these do not face crisis due to lesser pressure on the resources, e.g: Central Asian Region 4. Low Resources & high density -> the arithmetic growth of resources & geometric population growth leads to crisis, eg. West African crisis with ethnic conflicts & coup; eg. Urban centres with slums, poverty with extensive pressure on resources & land -> Contaminated water, unaffordable houses, Pollution
Checking malthusian checks - Resource expansion with innovation ([?]) in his S curve of Population growth - Agricultural revolution (HYVs) - ICT revolution - Medical revolution
Following the path suggested by Brutland commission we can tread on sustainable development to avoid crisis suggested by club of Rome.