Q.4) a) "The quantitative revolution in geography was a methodological turn rather than a philosophical one." Comment. (20 marks)
Rohin Kumar, AIR 39, 2025
Quantitative revolution is an attempt to systematise geography, revive its scientific approach, generalisation. It was underlined by ideas of Komte's positivism to move away from geography's enquiry for uniqueness.
Methodological turn 1. It focused on newer methods of Statistics - correlation, regression - predictive frameworks - hypothesis testing - locational analysis (gravity models) 2. It replaced the methods of sampling to remote sensing for data collection 3. The methods of data analysis were sophisticated to GIS with the golden [?] computers back then
Philosophical turn : yes 1. It focused on deductive empirical approach with reality as something that is observed 2. It rejected the Idiographic approach as seen in the Schaefer-Hartshorne debate, where normative questions were raised 3. It adopted quantification and generalisation with homogenisation of reality as the core frame of geography, seen in Models in Geography, Peter Hagget, RJ Chorley, David Harvey
However, QR was criticised by subsequent methods and Paradigms for: 1. Dehumanising geography by ignoring the normative questions, human experiences & perceptions cannot be ignored in deciphering reality 2. Marxist & radical geographers called for Changes as geography under QR could not answer qs of deprivation poverty 3. Limitations of models in depicting the reality, due to lack of applicability Worldwide, e.g. Economic rationality & Isotropic plain (weber) were challenged 4. The post-modern geographers raised pertinent Qs of gender equity, Sustainable development which could be answered by geographic models
Thus, GR was a significant watershed in the evolution of geographic in terms of methods, philosophy. However It is with human relevance [?] the discipline be justified properly.