Topper Copies

"A single definition of marriage cannot be applied to all cultures." Discuss with examples.

Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025

Seligman first define marriage as a union between a man and a woman such that children born to them are legitimate offspring of both the parents.

However, this definition is not universal because

Structure: union between man and woman 1. Excludes ghost marriages among Kwakiutl (from Boas study) 2. Exclusion of woman to woman marriages (Nuer of South Sudan) 3. Excludes polygamous marriages - Polygyny: Munda, Naga, etc [diagram: a boxed kinship symbol, circle-double line-triangle-double line-circle, labelled Polygyny] - Polyandry: Khasa → Jaunsar Bawar

Function: establish legitimacy of offspring However, in simple society legitimacy is not a function of law. Eg Toda's purusuthpimi (Bow & arrow ceremony) to establish fatherhood.

Thus, on the basis of her study among Nayar's, K. Gough tried to provide a near universal definition as, "A union between a woman and one or more other person Such that Children born to the woman under normal circumstances are accorded full birth status rights of members Common to their social stratum"

It tried to Cover, 1. Polygamous relationships: "a woman & one or more other persons." 2. Different conditions of parentage: "under normal circumstances not prohibited by rules of relationship." 3. Differential birth status rights: "Common to members of their social stratum."

However, it also excludes, 1. Na society of China, where formal marriage doesn't exist (Cai Hua (2001)) 2. Ghost marriages of Kwakiutl of British Columbia.

Thus, instead of devising a universal definition, scholars today prefer to define marriage based on its functions.