Topper Copies

Discuss the difference in approach of Victor Turner and Clifford Geertz to the study of performative aspects in rituals.

Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025

Victor Turner & Clifford Geertz views together clubbed in symbolism school of thought is an emic, non positivist approach to understand the [?] Culture of humans.

Clifford Geertz approach to rituals 1. Major works: Deep mind: thoughts on Balinese Cockfight, & other essays 2. Approach: known as interpretive approach, it views symbols as vehicles of "Culture" - The common [?] views surrounding the meaning of symbol in the mind of culture participant creates Culture. - Job of the anthropologist is to study & find out that common meaning of symbol. - Methodology - Hermeneutics: Anthropologist must step into the shoes of the subject & understand their view by identifying their options, limitations - Thick description: the phenomena observed must be explained in detail with full social context. - Culture exists as long as the society common meaning of symbols is there. - Eg Breakdown of Ikhs in Java once a political symbol was Conveyed as religious one in Javanese funeral.

Victor Turner approach to ritual 1. Major work: The forest of Symbols: aspect of Ndembu culture. 2. Approach - Symbols are objects of social process & they act to maintain Unity of society. - There are forces that try to disturb social unity & a society uses Symbols or rituals to reinforce the feeling of Communities to overcome the divisive forces. - Ex: the puberty rites among Ndembu under Mudyi tree, where mudyi tree acts as a symbol & bind the society together. - The feeling of liminality of Communities ensures continued existence of society & culture

Thus, both of them enriched the understanding of Anthropology regarding Culture & symbols.