Topper Copies

Critically discuss the formalist and substantivist approaches in the context of economic anthropology.

Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025

Karl polyani in "The great transformation" put forward the Substantivist view of economic study of simple society, countering the views of formalists.

Scholars associated 1. Formalism: Herskovits, schneider, etc 2. Substantivism: Polygni, Sahlins, Malinowski, etc

Formalists view of economic anthropology 1. They consider that the economics of Simple societies can be studied using principles of classical economics. 2. Principles like laws of demand & Supply, maximisation, rationality of human actions to avoid loss & maximise profit are considered to be applicable to simple societies as well. 3. They argued to treat simple economics as pure economics.

Substantivist view of economic anthropology 1. Scholars like Karl Polanyi argued that the simple societies economy are not pure economics but social economics, where social relations instead of rationality drive action. 2. Consider anthropologists to be capable of studying simple economies due to their consideration of social aspects 3. Substantivist rejected of formalism using ethnographic examples - for principle of maximization - Holds that human aims to maximise utility - Carneiro Study of Kuikuru of Amazon highlight they work merely for 3½ hour per day. If they work an hour longer they would be [?], however they don't care for maximising utility - Principle of rationality - Holds humans are rational in economic decision making - Potlatch among Kwakiutl of British Columbia where destruction of goods to enhance social standing taken place reject the principle of rationality - Law of demand & Supply - The exchange between Bantu Cultivator & Coastal fisherman in Africa do not follow principles of demand & supply as they Value social relations over profit

Criticism of approaches 1. Formalism - Principle of rationality is tautological - Avoid the studying social relations in economy - Fractional divorce of social reality from Economy. 2. Substantivist - Avoid some principles of economy like Bantu, etc that were there in simple economy

Both approaches enriched our understanding of simple society.