Topper Copies

Discuss the contribution of Franz Boas and his followers on nature-nurture debate.

Amit Meena, AIR 320, 2024

Franz Boas was a German-American anthropologist, regarded as the "father" of American Anthropology.

As a professor in Columbia University, Boas guided students like Kroeber, Wissler, Ruth Benedict and Margaret Mead.

Contribution on nature-nurture debate 1. Franz Boas → "Historical Particularism", which argued that many cultures developed independently. He focused on fieldwork to cover different aspects of the debate. His study of around 18,000 school children of European immigrants showed that in just one generation, the head shapes of children of long-skulled Nordic c[?] and murder rates since were becoming similar, pointing towards the effect of "nature". 2. Margaret Mead - "Coming of Age in Samoa" (1928): examined the rebellious nature of American adolescents was more due to cultural settings. Samoans was continuously changed, culture offering personality, thus emphasized on effects of "nurture" as mentioned in national character study. 3. Ruth Benedict - "The Chrysanthemum and the Sword" (1946): Japanese people were aggressive due to the "nurturing" aspect. 4. Ashley Montagu → found in the racial debate that pure race is a myth, and both nature and nurture lead to development of traits.

Criticism → by the Sociobiological Approach given by Wilson.

Thus the contribution of Franz Boas and his followers to the nature-nurture debate has been immense. And there is a need for adopting the bio-cultural approach to study this.