How do Descent and Alliance theories differ in their approach to understanding kinship systems in anthropology?
Amit Meena, AIR 320, 2024
According to Abercrombie, the social relationships deriving from blood ties (real & supposed) and marriage are collectively referred to as "kinship".
Two main theories emerged to explain the role of kinship in social structure and continuity:
Descent theory 1. Although tracing its origin in the works of evolutionists like Morgan and functionalists like Radcliffe-Brown, it came to fore in the 1940s, with works like "The Nuer" by Evans-Pritchard and "African Political Systems" by M. Fortes. 2. Descent theory compared unilineal descent groups to corporatism. Members of such groups behaved as a single unit dealing with economic, legal and political matters, as well as with other groups. 3. They concluded that descent, in particular unilineal, was the basis of stability and structure of a society in absence of state institutions. 4. Critic → kinship not always organised through unilineal descent, and it minimised the importance of marriage & affinal relations.
Alliance theory 1. Highlighted by Claude Levi-Strauss in his book "The Elementary Structures of Kinship" (1949). 2. Unlike descent theory, this theory put affinal relations as the basis of kinship and social structure. 3. Based on principle of reciprocity & the universality of incest taboo. 4. Marriage → reciprocal exchange involving women that forges a relationship, i.e. an alliance. 5. Incest taboo → forces men to marry outside descent group, dictating ever continuing reciprocal exchange, a positive marriage rule. 6. Levi-Strauss → these positive marriage rules give rise to elementary structure. 7. Critic → objectifying women (feminist Anthropologists), and it minimised the role of consanguinity & residence.
David Schneider - a critique - In his book "A Critique of the Study of Kinship" talks about how kinship didn't exist in any culture known to mankind. - According to him, the kinship studies were based on assumptions that were not necessarily valid across cultures. - He argued that various domains into which anthropologists divided social life, kinship, politics, economy, religion etc., had no analytical validity.
Having said that, kinship studies have helped shape the socio-cultural anthropology as well as the various schools of thought.