Topper Copies

How does Marvin Harris explain food taboos and preferences across different cultures.

Amit Meena, AIR 320, 2024

Cultural Materialism was coined by Marvin Harris, and it strives to create a pan-human science of society whose findings can be accepted on logical and evidentiary grounds.

Concept

Explaining food taboos and preferences 1. It says that infrastructure/material inputs mould and influence the structure and superstructure, to show how emic (native) thoughts and behaviours are a result of material considerations. 2. Sacred cow phenomena → as per Hindu tradition, the cow is sacred & killing it is tabooed, but in times of food distress, male cows are allowed to starve to death: an ideological aspect (superstructure) affected by an economic one (infrastructure). 3. Hindu taboo against beef → Harris explains that cows are more valuable alive than dead, providing essential resources like milk, dung, labour for agriculture. 4. Jewish & Muslim taboo against pork → in "Good to Eat" (1985), he explains that pigs are ecologically unsuited in the Middle East. He argues that raising pigs would be inefficient, costly, and they are a direct competitor in terms of feed (grains), thus making the taboo an adaptive strategy. 5. Meat consumption in high latitudes → Harris explains that harsh environmental conditions necessitate a diet rich in animal fat and protein, crucial for survival in Arctic and Antarctic regions.

Etic → Roy Rappaport's study on Tsembaga proves that superstructural elements like religion also equally impact infrastructure & structure.

Despite these, the theory has helped in adopting more scientific approaches to understand culture and food preferences.