How does Marvin Harris explain food taboos and preferences across different cultures.
Amit Meena, AIR 320, 2024
Cultural Materialism was coined by Marvin Harris, and it strives to create a pan-human science of society whose findings can be accepted on logical and evidentiary grounds.
Concept
Explaining food taboos and preferences 1. It says that infrastructure/material inputs mould and influence the structure and superstructure, to show how emic (native) thoughts and behaviours are a result of material considerations. 2. Sacred cow phenomena → as per Hindu tradition, the cow is sacred & killing it is tabooed, but in times of food distress, male cows are allowed to starve to death: an ideological aspect (superstructure) affected by an economic one (infrastructure). 3. Hindu taboo against beef → Harris explains that cows are more valuable alive than dead, providing essential resources like milk, dung, labour for agriculture. 4. Jewish & Muslim taboo against pork → in "Good to Eat" (1985), he explains that pigs are ecologically unsuited in the Middle East. He argues that raising pigs would be inefficient, costly, and they are a direct competitor in terms of feed (grains), thus making the taboo an adaptive strategy. 5. Meat consumption in high latitudes → Harris explains that harsh environmental conditions necessitate a diet rich in animal fat and protein, crucial for survival in Arctic and Antarctic regions.
Etic → Roy Rappaport's study on Tsembaga proves that superstructural elements like religion also equally impact infrastructure & structure.
Despite these, the theory has helped in adopting more scientific approaches to understand culture and food preferences.