Topper Copies

How do you relate the concepts of 'Sacred' and 'Profane' in Durkheim's theory of Religion with a focus on the role of Totem?

Amit Meena, AIR 320, 2024

The concepts of Sacred and Profane were developed by Emile Durkheim, a French sociologist, in his work, "The Elementary Forms of Religious Life" (1912).

- Religion, as per Durkheim, is the unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things. - The profane is the realm of routine experience dealing with mundane activities, eg: bed, computer. - Meanwhile, sacred refers to a set of rituals and objects set apart from profane by special prohibitions, dispensations, and prescriptions that do not pertain to everyday life, eg: Bible.

Role of totem 1. For Durkheim, religion is sacred, while magic is profane. 2. Religion is things, beliefs relative to sacred things, which unite into one single moral community, all those who adhere to them. 3. Durkheim regards the sacred-profane dichotomy as universal. In all religions, certain objects, rites and symbols are considered sacred. 4. To locate the source of sacred, Durkheim turned towards the Totemism of the Arunta tribe of Australia, which he regarded as the most elementary form of religion. 5. He found that the natives were divided into clans, each having its own totem. 6. Each clan shared a definite relationship with its totem, one which Durkheim called as that of "name". 7. He noticed that there is nothing inherent in an animal/plant/object, that is, the totem, which evokes a sacred attitude, eg → Kangaroo, Emu as totems. 8. Rather, it is the projection of beliefs upon the totem that makes it sacred. 9. Thus, the world of sacred came into existence through the unification of clan. The clan itself was symbolized and made visible through the totemic emblems.

Criticism 1. Evans Pritchard challenged the applicability of the dichotomy to real life situations, calling it non-useful in field research. 2. Jack Goody noted that many societies have no words that translate as sacred or profane and thus the dichotomy is not universal.

Thus the concepts do help us understand the theory of religion, but the challenges persist.