How does Julian Steward's concept of cultural ecology enhance our understanding of human-environment interactions?
Amit Meena, AIR 320, 2024
The term cultural ecology was coined by the American anthropologist, Julian H. Steward in his book, "Theory of Culture Change" (1955).
Concept 1. Steward called himself a multilinear evolutionist, concerned with the study of particular cultures. 2. To make systematic cross cultural generalisations, he provided a way to analyze man-habitat interaction in his cultural ecology model. 3. It represents the way in which cultural change is induced by adaptation to the environment. 4. Based on "core-superstructure" model, and he assumed culture as superorganic (learned from A. Kroeber). 5. Every socio-cultural system has a cultural core that is closely related to the economic and subsistence activities. 6. The system's technology is basic component of the core, but should be analyzed in terms of conditions of local habitat.
Enhances our understanding 1. Helps in determining how ecology influences unique historical cultural developments. 2. Cultural similarities and differences can be better understood. 3. Area based study → to holistically understand. 4. Analyze the interrelationship between technology and environment. 5. Behaviour patterns involved in exploitation of areas by technology. 6. Steward established that acceptance or rejection of diffused traits was dependent upon local ecology, i.e. interaction of envt, exploitative devices & socio-economic habitat.
Case Study → JH Steward's study on Shoshone Indians which showed their bare subsistence.
Criticism 1. Roy Rappaport - "Pigs for the Ancestor": many claim that institutions like religion (not just economic) can be the core of culture. 2. Marvin Harris → "opinions" and "core" of confusion.
Despite these, the concepts & approaches are used widely in various disciplines, specially in sustainable development. It also influenced Prof LP Vidyarthi to give the concept of NMS Complex.