Topper Copies

Do you agree with the view that family is a 'universal association'? Using suitable case examples, critically examine the above statement.

Amit Meena, AIR 320, 2024

Murdock in his "Social Structure" (1949) defined family as a social group "characterised by common residence, economic cooperation and reproduction. It includes adult of both sexes, which maintain socially approved sexual relation & one/more children."

- However, all the above features of the definition may not be found together in every society. - Structurally, a family can be nuclear, extended or joint family.

[three kinship diagrams, each drawn with the standard triangle (male) and circle (female) notation, labelled nuclear, extended and joint respectively]

Family as a universal association Murdock studied 250 societies through questionnaire and found that nuclear family existed in all of them. Thus, he concluded that nuclear family is universal.

He explains its universality saying that there are certain "essential" functions necessary for human survival, which can be performed only by nuclear families.

Essential functions 1. Permanent gratification of sexual needs. 2. Child birth. 3. Economic functions. 4. Socialisation of children.

Both extended and joint families have atleast one and two nuclear families. Thus, following Murdock, as nuclear family is universal, family itself must be universal.

However, that is not the case.

Not universal Kathlene Gough has given the following examples to show that the four essential functions are not universal domains of nuclear family:

1. Sexual needs & child birth - woman to woman marriage in Nuers - ghost marriages in British Columbia - Nayar Tharavad 2. Economic functions → modern welfare states have taken over many such functions - Societies like Kibbutz of Israel are also an exemption 3. Socialisation - In large extended families, it is done by grandparents - In modern West, due to high rate of divorce, frequency of single parent households have also increased

Further, Hwa Cai (2001) in his book "The Na of China" has clearly shown the lack of strong bond between man & woman, questioning the universality.

Thus Gough concludes that family is not universal, both structurally and functionally. She says only the mother-child unit is universal, with its sole universal function being primary socialisation.