Superorganic view of culture
Amit Meena, AIR 320, 2024
The Superorganic view of culture was first put forward by Emile Durkheim. However, it is A.L. Kroeber whose name is the most recognised with this view.
Superorganic view of culture 1. This view argues that culture and culture change cannot be explained by reference to any other discipline. 2. For Kroeber, culture constitutes a separate realm of phenomena and such it should be explained only in terms of its own laws. 3. This doesn't mean culture is inorganic, but that it is simply more than organic, i.e. superorganic. 4. It develops in an organic structure, but since it possesses qualities like changeability, collectivity, value pattern and transferability, therefore it should be called superorganic. 5. This concept was also adopted by other American Anthropologists like Lowie and White, and in British Anthropology, by Structural functionalism.
Criticism 1. Argued that since cultural phenomena occur in association with other psychological or ecological phenomena, it is untenable to separate them analytically. 2. Some critics argue that cultural phenomena do not have an independent existence and cannot be studied as if they had.
The superorganic view of culture continues to evoke regular debates in anthropology even to this date.