Formalist and Substantivist debate
Amit Meena, AIR 320, 2024
It is generally believed that economics is a specialised field that must be left to economics alone. Anthropology, in this regard, has two schools of thought.
Formalist School As per Herskovitz, Raymond Firth and Schneider, the economy of any society can be studied by the principles of economics alone, important being:
1. Principle of Maximisation → All humans aim to multiply their resources. 2. Principle of Rationality → humans are rational, whose actions aim at generating profits and preventing loss. 3. Principle of demand and supply.
Substantivist School Late Prof. Sahlins, Polanyi and Dalton argue that underlying basis of economy of simple societies is social. Hence Anthropologists are best suited to study economics, at least of simple societies.
1. Malinowski in his "Argonauts of Western Pacific" (1922) detailed about the Kula gift exchange among Trobriand islanders. 2. Kula, in economic terms, is an uneconomical and irrational venture involving hazardous voyages. 3. But Malinowski says it reinforces the kinship bonds and acts as a cement, without which society would disintegrate. 4. This shows that rationality in simple societies demand maintenance of social order even at cost of profit.
As Prof Sahlins says "Money is to West what kinship is to rest". Further Prattis argues that an interdisciplinary approach is needed. Best example being Amartya Sen's concept of welfare economics.