Discuss the ethical implications of withholding information in public administration. How can transparency enhance accountability and reduce corruption in government institutions?
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Right to Information is an implied fundamental right (Art 19) and is bedrock for good governance
Ethical Implications -> Public Administration
1. No checks and balances as no standards to judge, leads to more power and 'absolute power corrupts absolutely' 2. Chances of corruption as directly related to opacity :- Stealing when no scrutiny. 3. Citizen apathy, low consciousness of public role -> Reduces trust capital 4. Difficulty in measuring use of discretion :- Thus it may create fear of authority 5. No Dissent -> No Democracy. Information -> opinion -> dissent formation -> Thus threat to democracy 6. Threat to quality of public service delivery
Transparency enhance accountability 1. Accountability refers to answerability for actions and final outcome -> This criterion to judge (eg Annual reports of UPSC to judge its performance) 2. Scrutiny by NGO's, CSO's and judiciary
Reducing corruption 1. Enhance oversight over any use of public office for private gain (eg Minutes of meetings) 2. Highlight conflict of interest (eg Election affidavit showing interest in companies and monitoring whether benefit received by them) 3. Ideas like 'Judges electing judges'
(eg) Idea should be Tamso ma Jyotirmae... [From darkness to light] However transparency should be only through necessary procedures and to concerned stakeholders. Also some confidentiality is in public interest (eg Scheme formation (jurisprudence)