Topper Copies

"A single definition of marriage cannot be applied to all cultures." Discuss with examples.

Rasneet Kaur, AIR 51, 2025

Marriage is characterised as a universal institution which is present in all societies in one form or the other.

Since a long time there have been many efforts to devise a single universal definition of marriage.

Various Definitions of Marriage 1. George Murdock defined marriage as a social institution which involves:

Criticism i. Residential Cohabitation not followed in all cultures, eg Nayars of Kerala, husband and wife don't live together.

2. Westermarck defined marriage as: "a ritually and socially recognized bond between a male and female who have mutually exclusive sexual rights over one another".

Criticism i. Male and female bond doesn't apply everywhere, eg Female-Female marriages among the Nuer of South Sudan. ii. Mutually exclusive sexual rights not always; in some cultures extra-marital sexual relations are allowed, eg Yanomami of Amazon.

3. Kathaleen Gough defined marriage as: "a relation between a woman and one or more other person, where offsprings born out of such union get the Social status".

Criticism i. Ignores Male-Male Marriages, eg prevalent among the Chukchee of Siberia. ii. Ignores single parent relation, eg Basega of Central America, high divorce rates.

4. Stephen defines marriage as an institution that begins with a public proclamation and involves lifelong ties.

Criticism i. Does not take into account the fact that marriage is not always with social proclamation, eg Ghost marriage in Sudan (in secrecy).

In Contemporary times, with the coming of same sex marriages and live in relations, a universal definition becomes more difficult.