Differentiate between probity and integrity with suitable examples. How do these values contribute to ethical governance and decision-making in the civil services?
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
"Integrity refers to doing the right thing even when no one will know that you did it" - Oprah Winfrey
Probity refers to steadfast commitment to ethical values
| Probity | Integrity | |---|---|
Contribution of these
Ethical decision making 1. Safeguards from pressures and bias (eg Scheme favouritism for one caste) 2. Neutrality and impartisanship -> free and frank advice 3. Impersonal guide solving crisis of conscience (eg Gifts by relative appearing quid pro quo) 4. No conflict of interest
Ethical Governance 1. Proactive disclosures -> RTI 2. No special privileges to oneself, high scrutiny of self 3. Doing ought not for reward but joy of it :- Thus brings dedication to service 4. No corruption and strict compliance to AIS, 1968
Integrity and probity is what makes civil service, having civility and service mindset. It also hedges from fear and suboptimal performance (eg TN Seshan) and competing pressures (eg Gandhiji, in Non Cooperation...