Discuss the difference in approach of Victor Turner and Clifford Geertz to the study of performative aspects in rituals.
Rasneet Kaur, AIR 51, 2025
Victor Turner and Clifford Geertz are associated with Symbolic and Interpretative school of Anthropology.
Differences in Their Approaches to Study of Performative Aspects in Rituals
Victor Turner's Approach 1. Social Order is maintained through rituals which in turn are governed by symbols. Thus, Symbols = "operators in the Rituals". 2.
3. Study: Ndembu of Zambia, in the book "Forest of Symbols".
Ritual of feeding the milk sap from Mudyi tree to the child.
Mudyi tree → symbol of breast; Sap → symbol of milk; Ritual → reflects mother child bond.
4. Social drama involves rituals like:
5. Rites of Passage involve 3 stages:
Liminal stage marked by a feeling of solidarity: "Communitas".
Clifford Geertz's Approach 1. Interpretative approach → viewing the ritual from "Emic view", i.e. native's point of view. 2. Thick description:
3. Study: - Mourning Ritual among Javanese → different symbols carry a specific meaning - Deep Play: A Note on Balinese Cockfight → this ritual depicts the already prevalent social tensions and Competition
Some Similarities Too 1. Both refer to Rituals as the sum of symbols. 2. "Emic View" is the focus of both.
Thus, Victor Turner and Geertz provided transformative insights into the performative aspects of Various rituals.