Topper Copies

Discuss how the relationship between law and ethics is dynamic and continuously shaped by societal changes. Provide examples to illustrate this dynamic relationship.

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

Recent debates about marital rape and same sex marriage (decriminalisation of homosexuality) highlight evolving nature of ethics and interplay with law

Dynamic relations :- Shaped by Societal changes

1. Societal morality evolves (eg Women rights) -> Law is outcome of Society (eg Hindu Marriage Act) 2. Law related to transgenders (SDG 5) evolved (National Transgender Act, 2019) as sensitisation increased. 3. Ethics of Care by Carole Gilligan -> Incorporation has created ideas of welfare state and inclusive growth -> Laws like NFSA, 2013 providing right to food. 4. Environmental ethics -> Environmental jurisprudence (eg Doctrine of polluters pay, no harm, public trust and sustainable development reflected in law, institutions) (eg MK RanjitSinh case, eg NGT Act, 2013) 5. Nature of democracy

(eg) Citizen now asserting for good Governance (India Against Corruption) -> Lokpal Act, 2013

However at times, law also fuels social progression (eg Hindu Code Bill by BR Ambedkar; Constitution as transformative document)

Beyond leaders ethics, there exists a solid interplay As Gandhiji said, there is higher court, that is court of conscience, ethics should thus be foundation to implement spirit of law

| Law | | |---|---| | Surveillance issue | Dowry Act, 1961 | | Nazi Germany | Marital rape issue |

Ethics