Q.3 (c) Anthropological inquiry presents a holistic picture of complex realities about simple societies. Do you think this knowledge generated through anthropological inquiry can be useful for their welfare? Justify with examples.
Pankaj Patle, AIR 329, 2024
Sol Tax, mainly called as action anthropologist, preferred an active role of the anthropologist for development.
Anthropological Inquiry about simple societies 1. Understanding the ecosystem approach by L.P. Vidyarthi: Nature-Man-Spirit, Maler's mutualism on Khallu (Jhum) and benevolence of gosain spirit 2. Tribe caste continuum (F.G. Bailey): tribal not isolated but interaction with mainland caste 3. Economic system: Karl Polanyi, Great Transformation -> Alternate picture of substantivism, has embedded in kinship 4. Understanding Religion Belief -> Bongaism (Munda), power of Munda, totemism (Tiger) worships [?] 5. Taboos -> stigma around Menstruation eg [?], Hutu tribe, village -> land women 6. Health => evil spirits and dependent on Shaman to heal -> Bhumka in Korku, ethno medicine (P.C. Joshi) 7. Institutions - Political -> Khasi - S[?]em, pusha Raj (santhals), youth dormitory -> S.C. Roy (Dhumkuria), Ghotul guild
Using for Welfare 1. Political upliftment -> PESA 1996, 5th, 6th schedule (Bhuria com.) (protecting customs) 2. Integrated Health eg Abhay Bang committee: Traditional -> modern -> holistic health 3. Policy making eg) Tribal sub plan based on V.P. Vidyarthi Task force 4. Opposing unjustified eviction, rehabilitation eg) Amita Baviskan (In the valley of river, sardar sarovar) 5. Structural relativism to understanding tribal perspective eg) P.K. Bhowmik, Lodha tribes 6. Emic Approach -> development suitable to them eg) Koraput Coffee (Trifed) helped stopped productivity
Yet, some limitations: 1. More focus on data gather 2. Manipulation by NGO (eg Groups) 3. Ethic and objective findings 4. Over dependence on govt. donation restrict influential action
As said by L.P. Vidyarthi, the anthropologist can be a social doctor and engineer for tribals; that should be our guiding light.