Topper Copies

Q.3 (b) "Tribals in India had never been isolated communities." Comment.

Pankaj Patle, AIR 329, 2024

D.N. Majumdar defined Tribal as having Territorial affiliation, Endogamy, distinct culture and group solidarity.

However, colonial construct, Census 1931, showed tribals in primitive, animistic and isolated communities (ethnocentric bias) who are lagging in evolutionary ladder (Morgan): Savages -> Barbarians -> Civilization (Tribes).

Yet, in Indian scenario, isolated tribals don't fit in the framework: 1. G.S. Ghurye - Tribes are Backward Hindus eg. worship of Shiva, fertility, custom 2. Thakkar Bappa supported this 3. Role in Independence -> Birsa Munda Rebellion, Alluri Raju followed mainstream freedom movement 4. Tribe caste continuum (E.G. Baiga) Kondh, Mishra adopted caste factors. Bhumi Sanskritisation (Surjeet Sinha) -> Hence not isolated but spectrum and interactive 5. Little & great tradition -> Interacted with each other eg) Saluno festival -> Rakshabandhan 6. N.K. Bose -> Hindu method of tribal absorption 7. Ritualism (Interdependence of village) eg) Toda - pastoralism, Kusumba (Hunting) to Nilgiri villages 8. Sacred Complex by L.P. Vidyarthi -> forms basis of greater Indian civilisation 9. Health treatment and Ethnobotany, Healing by tribal shaman eg) Bhumka of Gond 10. T.K.'s survey of People of India showed greater exchange at various levels

Yet, some distinct features prove otherwise: 1. Religion - belief in spirits (Animism) rather than NMS complexes 2. Agriculture - Shifting cultivation ex) Jhum, Bewar, Podu 3. Youth dormitories -> S.C. Roy, Dhumkuria, Ghotul for [?]

This gave rise to a debate between Assimilation (Ghurye) and Isolation (Verrier Elwin). However, the middle path of tribal panchsheel by J.L. Nehruji was the guiding light to develop tribes on their own.