Q.3 (a) Critically assess the existing constitutional safeguards, plans and policies for tribal welfare.
Pankaj Patle, AIR 329, 2024
Tribal Communities form 8.6% of population of Country (2011 census). There are 705 registered tribes. Given the specific culture and features, based on Lokur committee, tribals were classified: 1. Geographic isolation 2. primitive culture 3. distinct from mainland 4. shyness of contact
Constitutional safeguards 1. Art. 15 -> prevent discrimination 2. Art. 16 -> equality in employment 3. Art. 25 -> To follow own religion 4. Art. 29, 30 -> protect the language 5. Art. 330 -> Reserved seat in loksabha 6. Art. 45 -> education for tribals 7. Art. 338 -> NCST
Plans for tribals -> 5th schedule areas. 6th schedule are Mizoram, Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura. - PESA 1996 (Bhuriya Commission) - Tribal sub plan (L.P. Vidyarthi Committee) - Integrated tribal development
Policies 1. Forest right act 2006 (for ownership right) 2. Decriminalisation of Notified tribe (Ayyengar Committee) 3. Health -> Ayushman Bharat scheme, Sickle cell elimination (2047) 4. Village development - Adi gram Yojana (Budget) 5. Van dhan Vikas (Livelihood mission)
However, in this Amrit kal, 75 yrs of independence, some lacunae are still there.
Critical appraisal 1. Land alienation (not following gram sabha) => Polavaram dam, eviction of Konda reddies 2. Non-submission of governors report (Bhuriya Committee) 3. Ignoring and biased approach for tribes eg FRA 2006, 42% claims accepted (NCST) 4. Health issues -> 65% Anemic women, 15% ANC visit, 59/1000 IMR (NFHS data) 5. Poverty -> still faced 43% BPL (NSSO), loss of livelihood due to covid 6. Indebtedness -> Hali, goti (Sahariya), Bonded labour (Juang), money lending 7. Diversion of DAPST funds to others 8. Environmental impact - climate change, Ladakh no fodder, Bakkarwals for cattles 9. Andamenese facing ground frost [?]
Yet, some positives of policies: 1. Trifed collaboration with amazon -> Dokra art of tribal at global level 2. Van dhan vikas yojana -> MSP for MFP, food park in Jagdalpur (Gond, music) 3. Land titles -> Chenchus (FRA 2006), Nallamalla forest 4. Samatha judgement guidelines
Way Forward 1. Bhuria committee -> detailed [?] report and Governor report 2. Constitutional articles not mere in letter but spirit 3. Verginius Xaxa - GIS, GPS to titling right of tribals 4. Idate commission - designation, govt reservation, DNT, NT, SNT
Tribal Interest- National Interest needs to be then only tribals can achieve holistic development. (Mungekar Committee)