In what ways the conception of the public sphere as theorized by Habermas has undergone a change in India?
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
Habermas talked about public sphere in his book "Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere".
He held that Public Sphere is the place where people come together and discuss the affairs of the State. They exchange opinions, information and discuss the policies and actions of the State.
He held that "ideal speech condition", "Communicative action" and a "discursive model of democracy" is necessary for a healthy public sphere.
Habermas argued that presence of freedom, civil liberties, platform, media etc. are crucial for public sphere.
He talked about structural transformation in public sphere from ancient times to modern world. Previously, salons, cafes, shops, community meetings etc. constituted public spheres and now arrival of media has altogether changed the public sphere.
Coming to the Indian context, Public sphere has undergone a massive shift in India. Previously during British rule, limited media in the form of journals, newspaper in vernacular, gatherings in community, Indian National Congress sessions were a part of public sphere which shaped the thoughts and opinions of the people.
After Independence, in 1970's and 1980's, the boom in electronic media like radio, newspapers, educated public opinions, schools, colleges, newsrooms, community spaces like parks etc. enriched the public sphere. It helped in political education of the masses and helped India to counter the "black era" of Emergency in late 1970's.
After 1990's, we saw a boom in Television Media where debates, discussions and deliberations enriched public opinion and acted as a political education medium of the masses. It influenced the government due to more informed public opinion.
After 2000's, we saw a revolutionary change in the form of arrival of social media, social media platforms became a platform for people to discuss affairs of the State. Platforms like Twitter, Facebook etc. became a hub of news circulation. Echo chambers, group formation on platforms, public posts about affairs of the State, comment section below the social media posts became engagement platforms for people to debate and discuss. The 'hashtag culture' has enabled people to raise their voices and gain support.
Governments held that public sphere shall be closely watched by State for good policies and decisions and to avoid threats. Threats like Toolkit case, fake news, disinformation, infodemics endanger the public sphere today.
So public sphere has to be used judiciously to achieve national goals and maintain a balance between personal freedom & national security.