"The end cannot justify the means, for the simple and obvious reason that the means employed determine the nature of the ends produced." Discuss with suitable examples.
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
"You cannot grow snakes in your backyard and expect them to bite only your neighbours" - Hillary Clinton
This quote explains how unethical means used by Pakistan led to unethical ends (eg Pakistan Taliban terror attacks)
Means determine end :- End = Aggregate of means
1. Individual using cheating, fraudulent means to get jobs -> eventually caught bringing social disgrace (eg UPSC controversy) 2. Freebies and criminalisation based politics + money power to win election :- If politics without principles, government formed will be extractive and biased 3. Use of violence to gain independence -> eventual unrest in country (eg African states marred to coups and dictatorship). Thus Gandhiji said means > ends. 4. Banality of evil :- Hannah Arendt - "All it takes for evil to triumph is few good men to do nothing" - 'Chalta hai' attitude & condoning bad is bad means. 5. Environmental domain - Development which was mindless, disregard to sustainable means -> eventually ends like Kedarnath disaster, Joshimath crisis 6. No distinction as mean is end to something and mean for some end -> Decision in continuum as life journey
However issue with means and ends is different perception of just and subjective categorical imperative (eg level of violence in freedom struggle)
Also at times, use of proportionate means for great ends can be justified (eg Doctrine of Proportionality and using it to curb internet, takedown...