Topper Copies

The Governor's role in Indian states has often been a contentious issue. Discuss in the context of recent political developments in Indian states.

Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025

The Governor is envisaged as a lynchpin between the states and centre (2nd ARC). He acts as the bridge of communication, facilitating cooperative federalism.

However, as S.C. Sorabjee says, the excessive interpretation of discretionary power of Governor under Article 163, 200, 213 etc has turned cooperative federalism into a bargaining one.

The recent case of Governor of TN vs. State of TN is a case in point. The misuse of Article 200 and Article 201 for forestalling the legislation of the democratically elected state government, aided by the constitutional silences (Article 201) -> doesn't provide a fixed timeline, has made the role a contentious one.

Similarly, this role as pardoning power too was misused, and was highlighted in the AG Perarivalan case (2023), under the exercise of Article 161.

The role of the Governor in recognising the government and its legitimacy has been another ground which time and again has widened the faultline of centre-state relations.

The legislation of the Kerala government to remove the role of Governor as the Chancellor of state universities, as recommended by the M.M. Punchhi committee (2007), has been a bone of contention.

The defamatory remarks made by the Governor of West Bengal against the Chief Minister has led to legal tussle between the two.

SC in cases like Shamsher Singh has ruled the partisan role of Governor. Similarly, in the Satyanarayana Choudhary case, SC said that the Governor is not an agent for the appointee of central govt and he has to show respect to the position.

Recommendation of the Sarkaria and Venkata Chaliah committee (2000) highlight that the person should be chosen with consultation of state govt., and should be such that he/she is able to take a distant view of the centre-state politics.

In the Nabam Rebia case, the SC has rightfully said the discretionary powers of the Governor are limited under Article 163, and his actions cannot be arbitrary, capricious or malafide. It should be dictated by reason, activated in good faith and tempered by caution.

As 2nd ARC says, the Governor rules with the iron hand and velvet glove; his role should be occupied with persons of acute honesty, integrity & non-partisanship.