Critically assess whether the current model of Panchayati Raj in India is compatible with the principle of participatory democracy or has it devolved into a mechanism of mere formal decentralisation?
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
The 73rd Constitutional Amendment of 1992 brought in the Panchayat Raj Institutions (PRIs) as the institutions of self-governance, realising the principle of subsidiarity.
The works of Esther Duflo and Jean Dreze highlight that PRIs have brought governance closer to people. Along with it, transparency, accountability and decentralisation of democracy have been some features.
In states like TN, Chhattisgarh, the representation of women has come close to 50%, beyond the mandate of 33%.
This has led to a better approach to allocation of public goods to women and the marginalized.
However, the Mani Shankar Aiyar committee highlights that the 73rd CAA has led to decentralisation of corruption.
Similarly, the RBI report on decentralisation highlights the lack of FFS: funds, functions, functionaries, and eventual functionality. There has been uneven delegation of functions and the delegation of responsibility has not been met with commensurate finances, hindering the progress.
Another ailing feature has been the existence of parastatal bodies that overlap with the PRIs' functions, making them mere implementers of social welfare mechanisms rather than institutes of self-governance.
Another glaring issue is the tied funds; this [?] Cheung calls INVERTED FEDERALISM. Tied funds with conditionalities make them underutilised.
Thus, there is a need for revitalising the third tier, with funds. The Vijay Kelkar committee recommended that the Finance Commission make one of the criteria of terms of reference "Decentralised governance", making direct contributions.