The evolution of Fundamental Rights jurisprudence in India reflects a shift from a textual to a purposive interpretation. Discuss this transformation with reference to landmark Supreme Court judgements.
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
Part III of the Indian Constitution provides for Fundamental Rights. It is rightly called the Magna Carta of the Indian Constitution, providing an exhaustive list of civil and political rights.
The Supreme Court was envisaged as a Sentinel qui vive, i.e. the guardian of these fundamental rights, and Article 32 forms the link between citizens and the judiciary, which Ambedkar called the 'heart and soul' of the Constitution.
However, this responsibility endowed on the Supreme Court has seen different interpretations. As the legend says, 'the constitution is what the judges eat for breakfast', highlighting the varying approach to interpreting the fundamental rights.
Beginning with a textual approach, the SC read fundamental rights only via its text and undermining the spirit. For example, the A.K. Gopalan case (1951), where SC relied only on the wording of 'procedure established by law', thereby taking a narrow view of FRs.
Similarly, the case of Shivkant Shukla vs ADM Jabalpur (1976) is a case of judicial regret, as it took the most narrow view of Article 21 and thereby reduced the scope of civil liberties. The textual reading undermined the scope and spirit of the FRs that were envisaged to liberate the citizens, and made them 'subjects' instead of citizens.
However, things changed with the Maneka Gandhi's case (1978), where SC shifted the stance to due process of law, laid the ground for purposive interpretation.
The purpose of upholding constitutional morality, due process and rule of law were ingrained in the SC's reading in cases like NALSA and Navtej Singh Johar, where it said constitutional morality should triumph over public morality.
Similarly, the Puttaswamy case of 2017, where it widened Article 21 to include privacy and brought the test of proportionality, arbitrariness and necessity into its jurisprudence. This made way for protecting women's rights like bodily autonomy in Suchita Srivastava, Sunita Tiwari case etc.
The purposive interpretativism is the hallmark of the "transformative constitution" that the Indian Constitution is, so said by Gautam Bhatia.
However, critics point out the scope of judicial overreach and judicial populism (Fali S. Nariman), in exercising the power in the name of judicial activism.
Thus, the SC has gone from a textual to an interpretative approach, emerging as the protector and guarantor of Fundamental Rights.