How far do you agree with the view that the National Green Tribunal (NGT) has met its objective of ensuring environmental justice in India?
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Recently Supreme Court of India declared right against adverse effect of climate change as Fundamental right (Art 14 & Art 21) in M.K Ranjitsinh case. This happens as we mark 10 years of NGT Act, 2013.
NGT in meeting Environmental Justice : Success
1. Specialised courts for disposing cases 2. Directives to States (eg Aravalli conservation to Haryana) 3. Emphasis on EPR in Waste Management seen in many cases 4. NGT as mediator in man animal conflicts and tribes' role in Protected Area network 5. Checks on government policy and notifications 6. Use of suo motu powers and summon to officials 7. Successful with regard to waste management 8. In line with Supreme Court environmental jurisprudence and implementation of it 9. Steps taken in Himalayan Disasters and conservation of biodiversity in Western Ghats
Challenges of NGT in Environmental Justice
10. Delays in disposing cases 11. No power with respect to cases like Indian Forest Act, 1927 (FRA 2006) 12. Appeal to decisions causing redundancy 13. Failure of government in ensuring appointment 14. Inefficiencies with regard to operation of regional benches -> Concentration of workload in Delhi
NGT should be pillar of environmental led development in times of climate change and climate disasters and apply CBDR principle within country.