Topper Copies

For Machiavelli, religion is a tool for political stability. Discuss this utilitarian view of religion and its implications for secular governance.

Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025

Niccolo Machiavelli in his book The Prince wrote that the Prince should follow dual morality. He should not be bound by the ethics of religion and only focus on national interests.

He separated ethics of religion from the realm of politics. He advocated that the Prince should not appear irreligious and should seem religious in public, even if he is not.

This he called the utility of religion to meet the ends of national goals. He saw religion as an instrumental goal; people can be controlled via religion and disciplined.

The implication of such a utilitarian view on secular governance has inspired "secularism" politics. For example, SKKinner says Machiavelli was the first philosopher who separated religion and politics and freed politics from the metaphysics.

The laicite of France (or) the wall of separation of USA both find roots in Machiavelli's view of religion.

This, in a multiethnic society, may help in bringing good governance without inciting/favouring any one group.

However, critics like Thomas Aquinas & St. Augustine say using religion as an instrument of discipline and control is a narrow view of religion.

Augustine gives the concept of "moral religion": religion is inherently good and helps in the governance as well as development of the individual.

The negatives of such an instrumental use is the appeasement politics as highlighted by L.K. Advani in the Indian context.

Similarly, it may lead to ghettoisation of few groups and alienating them from the process of governance.

(5) Sachar Committee report

Thus, Machiavelli was the founding father of modern secularism in a way.