Gandhism and Marxism converge on a moral critique of industrial capitalism despite their methodological differences. Examine.
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
Marx said the capitalism carries the seeds of its own decay, while Gandhi critiqued capitalism as satanic, bringing about the destruction of man and nature.
Gandhiji focused on production of masses rather than mass production, writes Jait...? Rao in his book "the economist Gandhi".
Gandhi advocated decentralized production aided by cottage and small industries.
He said industrial capitalism isolated the workers and led to surplus creation at the expense of resources of earth.
"The earth has enough for man's needs but not his greeds."
This highlighted his stark critique of capitalism in the satanic destruction of the ecology while violating the dignity of labour.
Karl Marx too was the foremost critic of industrial capitalism. He writes in his Economic & Philosophical Manuscripts that capitalism leads to alienation, and subjugation of the working class under the bourgeoisie.
"Capitalism will die under the weight of its own contradiction," writes Marx. The contradiction he pointed was the mismatch in surplus and distribution of benefits.
However, while Marx advocated dictatorship of the proletariat, Gandhi advocated trusteeship.
While Marx advocated control of the means of production by the working class only, Gandhiji advocated for coexistence of industries and cottage. Gandhiji was not against industrialisation per se. He was only against uncontrolled industrialisation.
On the other hand, Marx saw capitalism as bad and an instrument of the bourgeoisie and wanted to capture it by the working class revolution.
Thus, while both advocated against capitalism at some points, they diverge in the latter stages with respect to control and distribution of surplus.