Topper Copies

Comment on the following in about 150 words: Distributive Justice

Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025

Justice forms the core part of normative political theory and is a contested and contextual concept.

The views of Plato and Aristotle have dealt with it, with both of them accepting the natural inequality of men. At the same time, they advocated proportionate equality as a way to bring justice. The basis of such equality is distributing the rewards based on the proportional contribution.

This changed with the rise of social egalitarianism, especially John Rawls' Theory of Justice who advocated justice via veil of ignorance with original position. He gave the idea of difference principle to help distribute the resources to the least advantaged.

Similarly, Dworkin advocates equality of resources via just initial distribution and holding people accountable to their choices and not circumstances.

However, neoliberalists critique it, for example, ROBERT NOZICK, say patterned distribution of justice as against the principle of non-interference and it is forced labour.

Similarly, Amartya Sen calls the capabilities approach - without capability, mere distribution is just procedural and not substantive justice.