Governors in India often overstep their constitutional role and fail to act effectively when needed. Comment.
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Art 153/154 talks about governor as Head of State executive. Recently, governor is in controversy especially in Opposition ruled States (eg Kerala, Punjab).
Overstepping Constitutional role
1. Not acting on Aid and Advice of state elected representative (eg Not assenting to Bill's in Kerala) 2. With regard to legislature: regarding summoning of legislature (eg Punjab case) -> change in governor's address (eg Tamil Nadu) 3. From representative of Centre -> agent of Centre -> indulging in political debates, political jibes and partisanship 4. Issues and disputes with regard to 5th and 6th Schedules -> issue seen in Ladakh, North East. 5. Not following spirit of Constitution.
However this immunity and Constitutional discretion not exercised when needed.
Failure when needed
1. No report imposing Presidential rule in Manipur (Art 356) 2. No role in solving distrust and deadlock between states 3. Jharkhand governor not acting on advice given by ECI in Mining case. Neither was report made public 4. Inaction in appointment of Speaker in Maharastra (2022), leading to crisis. 5. Role of LG in Delhi and continuous tussle in COVID.
Way Forward
1. Governor only a symbolic and titular head. 2. Spirit of Constitution and Supreme Court judgements followed (eg Ram Jawaya case) 3. Stability of tenure to governor 4. Following recommendations of (Sarkaria & Punchi) Commission
Various governors have also led by example and showed way for collaboration by giving will of people as Supreme.