Discuss the Rationale behind affirmative policies. Do you think that affirmative action policies with respect to women can address the disadvantages faced by them?
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
Affirmative policies refers to a positive discrimination in the favour of disadvantaged sections of the society to bring them at par with others.
John Rawls' Difference principle for "democratic equality", Iris Marion Young's "Differentiated citizenship" etc. advocate for affirmative action policies.
social liberal scholars hold the view that certain sections of society may be disadvantaged like Blacks in USA, Dalit in India. So we need an affirmative action to help them come out of disadvantage. for eg: Indian reservation system.
Equality of opportunity as advocated by classical liberals like Nozick can lead to discrimination against disadvantaged sections, social liberals go for a "fair equality of opportunity" by affirmative actions for equitable development instead of equal development. We have to go for an equitable distribution of resources. Joseph Stiglitz and Amartya Sen held that Indian reservations have led to equitable development of SC's, ST's & OBCs proving efficiency of affirmative actions without compromising the merit.
However, classical liberals like Nozick critiques it as an attack on dignity of others. Socialists critique them as justification of inequalities and they are also criticised as a compromise of merit by the critics.
Women have been a "secondary sex" as per Simone de Beauvoir. So we need affirmative actions to help women move out of patriarchy. Feminist perspective of state led by the Catherine McKinnon believe that state can improve the position of women in society. They talk about "personal is political" [illegible]. It means society is repressive but state can work for betterment of the women.
Affirmative actions have improved position of women, for example, reservation to women in local bodies under 73rd and 74th amendment acts have led to 45% representation of women in them whereas it is just less than 14% in Lok Sabha [illegible] and 9% in state legislative assemblies where there is no reservation as per PRS. Nari Vandan Adhiniyam providing 33% reservation was necessary to uplift women, however scholars like Amartya Sen held that affirmative action policies may be good in short-term but in long-term we need a more comprehensive approach to deal with inequalities & disadvantaged sections.