Define Cultural relativism and compare the cultural relativist perspective of Human Rights with the universalist perspective of Human Rights. Do you think there can be a way to reconcile these two different perspectives on Human Rights?
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
Cultural Relativism as propounded by Franz Boas, held that culture is the part and parcel of one's identity, we have to accomodate cultural diversity in our conception of human rights to make them acceptable to all.
cultural relativists held that we have to take a more substantive view of culture and community and about their importance in one's life. They held that man is 'embedded self' or 'situated self' and his cultural values shape his conception of rights, for e.g. female genital mutilation is common practice in Somelia but it is unthinkable in the west.
Cultural relativist perspective of Human rights criticises the the universal nature of Human rights as envisioned in Universal declaration of Human Rights [1948].
They held that western cultural values cannot supersede other cultures. west has to respect the cultures of others and also the sovereignty of other countries.
Cultural relativist perspective has given birth to arguments like 'Asian values' where they differ with the western concept of universal rights based on liberalism.
They point out that under the guise of protection of human rights, western countries & achieve their geopolitical objectives to maintain their hegemony. for example USA's actions in Libya in 2011 when Nato took down regime of Muammar Gadaffi, by military actions.
Human rights is an industry now where people make quick money and cultural relativists hold that the west finds them to create instability.
Cultural relativists held that Human rights concept violate the dignity of other cultures and it has become a basis of "clash of civilizations" concept of Huntington.
They hold that instead of a universalistic approach of human rights, we have to take a particularist approach. However cultural relativist perspective is criticised by cosmopolitan scholars who take it as a roadblock in emergence of a universal/cosmopolitan culture. feminists hold that cultural relativism is bad for women as Hillary Clinton held that "human rights are women's rights".
These two perspectives can be reconciled by Bhikhu Parekh's "cosmopolitan approach" based on the "dialogue among civilizations" and "harm principles" of J.S. Mill. He held that the west cannot claim supremacy and we have to accommodate other models of rights through dialogues and discussions which can harmonise the both conceptions.
So, a "middle path" or "Golden mean" between both of the perspectives through dialogue can be the way forward for a more peaceful world.