Topper Copies

Rights as Trumps.

Vikas, AIR 27, 2025

Dworkin gave the idea of rights as Trumps. Griffin defined rights as something without which nobody can realise "his/her best self".

Dworkin held that the rights of an individual has to be given consideration over anything else. His views are seen "in the context" of the debate whether" Rights are prior to Good" or not.

Dworkin held that rights of an individual are absolute and they shall not be taken away. Even common good or the community interest is not the excuse to take away rights of the individual.

Rights are also available against the government or authority to an individual. Government cannot take away these rights by any ordinary piece of legislation. In sum, Dworkin upheld that Rights of an individual shall triumph over all other things.

However, Laski in his book "The Grammar of Politics" gave his theory of rights and held that rights are [dynamic] and they depend on time, place and context. Dworkin's absolute rights stance without corresponding duties is also criticized by Laski when he held that Rights are present in duties in embryonic sense.

However, despite criticism, Dworkin's emphasis on rights of an individual is commendable especially in times of democratic recession [Governments], eroding civil liberties around the world and bolstering authoritarianism in form of "China Challenge".