Social contract theory of the origin of the state is bad history, bad logic and bad philosophy.
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
Social contract theory is propounded by scholars like Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau.
It is built upon the human nature, state of nature and the context and objectives for the formation of state. It envisions that in state of nature, there were some difficulties as per them and then humans entered into social contract to create a state.
∴ It is bad history because, There is lack of consensus among scholars themselves, Hobbes called state of nature as painful but Rousseau called it a "state of bliss".
Before the modern states, these were monarchies in rule, almost everywhere in the world so how people will give to some other people, their powers and permission to use that powers against them making it a bad psychology. It is also a bad philosophy, because if we transfer all of our powers under the contract, the state can become fascist and totalitarian which can be detrimental or suicidal for the people.
However social contract theory cannot be disregarded as utter fallacy. It has helped us to understand the evolution of human nature, society and state in a better way. views of social contract theory thinkers are like a bedrock for scholars of political philosophy in later times.