Topper Copies

"Like men, like State; governments vary as the characters of men vary........." - Plato. Critically Evaluate. (200 words, 15 Marks)

Nikita Verma, AIR 30, 2025

Plato is regarded as the greatest political philosopher. He believed that "state is individual writ large" He believed that just like men even state has characteristics & Justice is the guiding principle of all.

Plato has given the myth of metals for men. He believed that in every man there are certain components like,

- Men of Temperance -> Men of Copper - Men of Courage -> Men of silver - Men of Knowledge -> Men of Gold

In each individual, all three characteristics exist, but one of them nominates.

Men of copper are many in number, while men of silver are few & men of gold are fewer.

In order to attain happiness, man should follow the virtue associated with it.

Similarly, In a state there are several individuals with different virtues.

Justice is the architectonic principle. So, every individual should try & achieve his telos.

The role of Philosopher King is to be establish Justice or RIGHT POSITIONING where every individual is practicing his virtue

Plato is often criticised for promoting inequality & giving rise to dangerous ideologies like fascism.

But is to be noted that Plato preferred to support harmony instead of hollow equality.

Plato is also criticized for promoting social divisions & justifying dangerous practices like "white man's burden"

Karl Popper called Plato as enemy of open society.

Nonetheless, the notion of Justice given by Plato holds relevance even today and act as a guiding light.