Topper Copies

"Dear is Plato, but dearer still is truth"- Aristotle. In the light of the above statement establish that Aristotle is not only the greatest disciple of Plato, but is also his greatest critic. (200 words, 15 Marks)

Nikita Verma, AIR 30, 2025

ARISTOTLE is regarded the greatest disciple and greatest critic of Plato.

Plato had given an idealised view of state, politics, reality & had disregarded world of matter as a mere reflection.

Plato's ontological view was that Idea is reality & this world/phenomenal world is a mere reflection of it.

Aristotle also believed that Idea is reality. But ontologically he believed that the world of matter can't be neglected altogether. It is important to study.

Epistemologically; since idea is real, to get true knowledge Plato believed in dialectics For Aristotle, since both idea & matter are relevant true - for empirical study & dialectics is needed.

Plato has given the concept of Allegory of Cave. Aristotle has given the Theory of Causation & Theory of Potentiality & Actuality.

Plato's ideal State is Philosopher King, Aristotle accepts it is as ideal but considers Polity as the best practicable form of government.

Despite these differences, both these thinkers belong to SOCRATIC TRADITION & emphasise on the role of ethics in politics. Both are critic of sophist tradition.

Whitehead believed that entire political thought is nothing but footnotes to the works of Plato & Aristotle.

Thus, Aristotle presents an alternate of CIVIC REPUBLICANISM. For him, Plato is dear but truth is dearer.