Topper Copies

"Right is prior to good". Critically examine.

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

This is the defining statement of liberalism. liberal schools focus on primacy of man over Society. They are individualistic in nature.

liberal states guarantee Rights to man to protect himself against society or state. locke, father of liberalism gave theory of Natural Rights.

Natural Rights tradition says man has unalienable Right to life liberty and property which can't be sacrifice for greater good of Society.

Similar views are upheld by J.S. Mill who says 'liberty' is the most important right.

Rawls, while criticising utilitarianism says 'individual rights can't be sacrificed in the name of Greatest happiness of Greatest number.'

This idea is based on Kant's dignity principle which says 'each man is end in itself.' Thus, individual rights has primacy over society/collective good.

Liberal state also allows individuals to determine their own good and only ensure enabling conditions by way of guaranteed Rights. This is in line with Isaiah Berlin Value Pluralism.

But communitarian argue that rights are not prior but embedded in good. Michael Sandel says that man is embedded self, and 'notion of good' shapes man's rights.

For instance, Indian values prioritise collectivism/common good over individual rights.

But 'rights' are trumps as suggested by Dworkin, they are not to be compromised. This is endorsed in UDHR.