Topper Copies

Compare Austin's theory of Sovereignty with that of Pluralists

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

In a definite territory, if any human superior, not in a habit of obedience to like superior, receive obligation from bulk of society, then that superior is state.

This explains the complete theory of sovereignty given by Austin, to concentrate all powers in State. State became only source of law & power of enforcement.

Monistic theory is also supported by Hobbes who call state as 'leviathan' means supreme authority.

Pluralist theory emerged in the context of World war II when it was realised that monistic theory has led to state's excesses on people & harm to international peace.

Laski said 'Society is federal, so authority must also be federal'. This mean devolution of sovereignty to other institutions as well such as UN.

MacIver also suggest state as only one of the institution and general will is people's will. State is in fact child & protector of law, not source.

Pluralist theory is desirable for peace & accountability of state.