While the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) plays a crucial role in combating corruption, its functioning is often criticized for being partisan and acting against the federal spirit. Discuss with the help of suitable examples.
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
CBI gets its powers from Delhi Police Special Establishment Act, 1946 and is an executive body.
CBI and role in combating corruption
According to Transparency International corruption refers to use of public office for private gain.
Criticism -> Being Partisan : Why?
1. CBI is termed as a caged parrot as its appointment is done by (PM, LOP, CJI) but based on executive recommendation (eg Recent case allowing extension to CBI director for 3 years, 1 year at a time) 2. No Constitutional or legislative backing or immunity 3. No stability of tenure 4. Funds are not charged from Consolidated fund of India 5. Instances of corruption in CBI itself 6. Used against opposition members 7. low conviction rate and process being punishment.
Criticism :- Acting against federal Spirit : why?
8. Recently states like Punjab and West Bengal withdrew general consent of CBI 9. CBI investigating in law and order cases which is a state subject 10. Sometimes CBI and state functionaries are at loggerheads (eg CBI people were welcomed with stones in West Bengal) 11. Political extension of ruling party. Such is perception of CBI in recent decades 12. Delays in filing chargesheets 13. Sporadic actions (eg Delhi CM arrested on CBI charge as soon as he got bail). Thus seen as instrument to violate federal spirit
Way Forward
1. legal backing 2. Stability of tenure (2 years) should be rule; no reappointment 3. Removal also by collegium 4. State role in appointment
Recommendations of Santharam and 2nd ARC.
CBI as premiere investigative body should insulate itself from politics and lead by example as cases of transboundary corruption rise.