Topper Copies

"Aristotle differs from his master Plato, much more in the form and method than in the substance of his thought" (Dunning). Critically examine.

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

Aristotle is called as father of political science for his contribution to this field. He is also known as the greatest disciple as well as greatest critic of Plato.

Aristotle differed from Plato on various fronts: 1. Method — Aristotle believed in 'Golden mean as golden rule', while Plato aims for perfection. This difference is visible when we compare Plato's theory of Philosophy king and Aristotle's polity. Aristotle said 'Philosopher King' is best but polity is best practicable as the King would be a tyrant. 2. Aristotle is conservative while Plato was radical, and sometimes out of this world. Plato's theory of communism is criticised by Aristotle as 'medicine worse than disease', he goes for preserving age old institutions of marriage & property. 3. Aristotle doesn't agree with Plato' theory of idea being only reality. He said idea & matter coexist and real world is also important. 4. While Plato goes for Rule of wisdom of Philosopher king, Aristotle criticise it saying 'laws are reason without passion' thus Rule of law is preferred.

Though they differed in method & form, yet they come on common grounds when looked deeply.

Aristotle and Plato both aimed at making Athens an ideal state. They both looked at state as a source 'of virtue and go for complete obedience to state.

Their idea of justice is also somehow similar. While Plato goes for differentiating people on the basis of soul, Aristotle favored slavery, and said it's unjust to treat unequal equally.

They both belong to idealist tradition which rely on 'reason' of man and 'man as social/political being.'

Yet they differ in substantial manner as plato makes no difference 'in personal & political while Aristotle do.

It's rightly said that 'Entire Western thoughts are nothing but footnotes of Aristotle and Plato'.