Topper Copies

How does the debate around the Rawlsian notion of justice have made justice a pluralistic concept?

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

Justice is an architectonic concept and most foundational value in political science. Thinkers from the time of Plato have deliberated upon Justice, producing diverse notions.

Rawls is credited for revival of political science & normative theory with his Theory of Justice.

In this theory, he use hypothetical device of 'veil of ignorance' and 'original position' to arrive at principles of justice without any biasness.

People are gathered for deciding principles of distribution of public primary goods. They decide: 1. Maximum equal liberty 2. Equality of opportunity 3. Max. advantage to least advantage

These principles are lexical order.

How it lead to debates and made Justice pluralistic:

These principles of Justice has been criticised by Communitarians as they focus on role of community in man's life. Michael Sandel says man's embedded/situated self & Rawls' man is atomistic.

Micheal walzer says 'Justice' is not the science of homogenisation, but the art of differentiation.

This means that these principles can be applied everywhere as there are differences in societies & between societies.

Similarly feminist view of Justice came up, criticising Rawl's contract as masculanist (Kate Millet' Sexual contract). 'Gender' should be accounted in these principles.

Marxist scholars have their own notion of justice as giving everyone share in resources, ensuring equality of outcome.

While Dworkin go for ensuring equality of resources, Amartya Sen takes a step forward & focus on equality of capabilities.

Neoliberals like Nozick critique Rawls and gave Entitlement theory of Justice which focus on 'merit' and 'liberty'.

Thus, these debates surrounding Rawls idea enriched Justice as a pluralistic idea which helped in ensuring welfare state & just society. Rawls theory become starting point of Justice & its journey.