Critically examine the relevance of the theory of nuclear deterrence in preventing war in the International system.
Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024
Thomas Schelling defines nuclear deterrence theory as a psychological tool (game theory) in state's arsenal to protect states from falling into trap of full-fledged hot-war.
A lot many experts have praised the theory for preventing war. For instance, the presence of nuclear arsenals with India & Pakistan have prevented both from even starting a conventional war post-1999 Kargil.
Likewise, presence of nuclear arms is important according to realists like Waltz & Mearsheimer for stopping wars & maintain balance of powers.
However, it is criticized as presence of nuclear weapons has not created deterrence. For instance, it has not stopped Ukraine (non-nuke) to attack Russia (nuke state)
Likewise, form of warfare has changed as seen in - Iran led Houthis attacking US & Israeli ships in Red Sea via drones -> Neo-classical
Realist approach hints that leaders like Kim Jong UN (N. korea) are susceptible to use these any adversary very likely.
Thus, responsible usage of nuke-weapons & global acceptance of TPNW treaty can make deterrence effective.