Topper Copies

Critically examine the relevance of the theory of nuclear deterrence in preventing war in the International system.

Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024

Thomas Schelling defines nuclear deterrence theory as a psychological tool (game theory) in state's arsenal to protect states from falling into trap of full-fledged hot-war.

A lot many experts have praised the theory for preventing war. For instance, the presence of nuclear arsenals with India & Pakistan have prevented both from even starting a conventional war post-1999 Kargil.

Likewise, presence of nuclear arms is important according to realists like Waltz & Mearsheimer for stopping wars & maintain balance of powers.

However, it is criticized as presence of nuclear weapons has not created deterrence. For instance, it has not stopped Ukraine (non-nuke) to attack Russia (nuke state)

Likewise, form of warfare has changed as seen in - Iran led Houthis attacking US & Israeli ships in Red Sea via drones -> Neo-classical

Realist approach hints that leaders like Kim Jong UN (N. korea) are susceptible to use these any adversary very likely.

Thus, responsible usage of nuke-weapons & global acceptance of TPNW treaty can make deterrence effective.