Discuss the contribution of comparative methods in understanding the political systems. Also briefly mention the challenges of comparative politics in the context of globalisation.
Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024
Alexis de Tocqueville wrote that - "without comparisons to make, the mind does not know how to proceed"
Therefore, comparative politics is an important sub-discipline as it analysis & compares the structure of state, its institutions, organisation and political system.
Comparative politics has made immense contributions.
Traditional methods inspired by Aristotle, analysed state & government to answer the question of liberty, equality, justice.
Post-WWII inspired by David Easton's behavioural movement, empirical approaches were developed.
Systems approach analysed political systems rather than states to understand structure. According to this approach, political system interacts with environment to convert inputs into outputs for authoritative allocation of values.
Likewise, structural-functionalist approach by Almond & Powell compares the functions of structure for comparison of states. For instance, both India & China have legislatures yet both perform different functions.
- India → lawmaking - China → puppet of party
(China is a party with a state attached to it... -Vijay [?]).
Political-sociology approach understands society in order to look at system. For instance, Rajakosthami's politicisation of caste is based on this approach as caste remains the breath-line of Indian politics.
Amartya Sen & Jean-Dreze has used political-economy approach to study inequality in India-China
Top 10%
| | 1950s | 2010s | |---|---|---| | India | 31% | 70% | | China | 28% | 41% |
In India, inequality rose more severely.
However, it's fraught with challenges. As it leans into over-simplification and false paradigm of value-neutrality (systems approach). For instance, post-colonial societies are too complex to ever simplified.
It's eurocentric as it portrays democracy & western liberal democracy as the ideal systems (Marxists).
Its bias as polit-economy approach argues that - country with weaker trade unions are economically efficient.
Yet, Comparative analysis is important to merge scienticism with normativism (neo-institutional approach).