Evaluate the Marxist assertion that International politics is driven by the interests of the capitalist class rather than the interests of states. How does this view challenge the fundamental assumptions of Realist and Liberal theories?
Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024
Karl Marx in Das Kapital wrote that:- "the expansionist nature of Capitalism pushes bourgeoisie to nestle & settle everywhere".... It's on this premise that Marxist analysis of International politics is built.
Marxist criticizes the expansionist nature of capitalism for breeding global class struggle & anarchy.
For dependency school theorist like Immanuel Wallerstein the world's divided into core: developed & periphery: developing countries. The core is dominated by the capitalist class), reaffirms their status.
For profits & surplus value, capitalists promotes corporate globalisation - putting companies/factories/office everywhere to earn more.
Like Lenin, neo-marxist like Gramsci, Robert Cox argue that western capitalist class has used ideological hegemony to rule our world. Like democracy promotion (BUSH doctrine), neo-liberalism through Washington Consensus etc.
Thus, Marxist differs from realists, who claim that anarchy (Morgenthau) is the driving force for zero-sum diplomacy in world. Rather, it's the bourgeoisie's interest which derives the wheels of world.
Similarly, they differ from liberal-idealist who claim that liberal-institutionalism (Keohane & Nye): peace through global Institutions is possible. Rather, they point how UN, Brettonwoods (WB, IMF) etc. reflect "continuing-hegemony" of west (Chris Harman).
However, Marxist claim has also become redundant amidst China becoming world's capitalist engine & Vietnam becoming Schumpeterian-competition state (Bob-Jessop). Triumphalism of liberal democracy (Fukuyama) can't be accepted worldwide.