Topper Copies

The greatest liberty of the subject consists in silence of law (Hobbes). Comment.

Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025

Hobbes is regarded as the first modern Thinker as he gave a very elaborate justification for 'sovereignity of state'. Hobbes was a 'child of his times'. He witnessed the Puritan revolutions and the Spanish Armada and thus forms a negative view of human nature and gives absolute power to state.

Hobbes's main concern is security and not liberty. Thus, in his contract he gives absolute powers to the state and even gave the state, right to punish if someone disobey the law. He held that, 'Covenants without sword, are nothing but words and of no use'.

Thus, only liberty available to man is where law is silent, i.e state has not formed law. In the state of nature, man was living with 'natural law or natural rights'. However Hobbes does not regard, natural law as real law. For him, they are 'counsels of prudence'. The only law which is valid, is the law created by the state.

Hobbes views are based on his experiences of the events happening during his time. Locke took the contract of Hobbes further and advocated natural law, no liberty. For Locke, natural law is important and the state cannot take away right to life, liberty and property.

However Hobbes's state is sovereign and can take the right to life in a manner written in law i.e procedure established by law. Thus Hobbes' gives state absolute rights. Hobbes was criticized by the church which burnt copies of his book 'Leviathan' as he even kept the church under the sovereignty of state.