Topper Copies

Give reasons for Aristotle's preference for the mixed constitution. Do you think Polity is the best practicable form of government? Substantiate your point of view.

Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025

Aristotle is regarded as 'Father of Political Science'. He adopted an empirical approach and studied the constitutions of 158 countries to come to a logical and balanced conclusion.

Aristotle held that Polity is the best practicable form of government. It is the golden mean of oligarchy (rule of few rich) and Democracy (rule of many poor). Polity is the rule of 'middle class'. According to Aristotle, the middle class prefers stability and thus the state or ruler should try to bring people in the middle class to ensure a stable government.

Aristotle stands for 'golden mean as the golden rule' and hence he preferred the mix of constitutions. Rule of few rich and many poor are undesirable. Democracy leads to tyranny of majority which also inspired J.S. Mill. Even Machiavelli held that the Prince should take the side of middle class and not the oligarch.

In the context of India, we can see how electoral politics is influenced by majoritarianism and policies that are not deliberated and discussed. Ambedkar's ideas are relevant. Even Winston Churchill was a critic of majoritarian democracy.